Build Date: Fri Nov 28 06:00:16 2025 UTC
I hate this keyboard...as soon as I send this message - one piece becomes many.
-- Johnnie Royale
GNUisance: Pigdog Journal Interviews Richard Stallman
 Non-free documentation |
ES: What do you think of, of Tim O'Reilly's uh, argument about, uh, "free documentation"? RS: It's bullshit. He's just ignoring the issue. Basically, he's starting from the assumption that the world must be set up in such a way that O'Reilly and Associates can make money by publishing documentation for Free Software. This is an assumption that I don't share. I think that it would be no tragedy if there were no O'Reilly and Associates. And then he makes _another_ assumption that I think is probably also wrong, based on my experience, which is that he couldn't make money selling copylefted manuals. Well, I think he can. The Free Software Foundation does. So, uh, so, these two wrong assumptions are at the root of what he's saying. Now, I, let me say what's he's probably going on. He speculates, and he may well be right, that he would make less money selling [copylefted] manuals, and he doesn't want to make less money. He wants to make more money. |
MB: But at the same time -- and this is what I've argued actually about this very issue -- is that O'Reilly makes a lot of money from Free Software. I mean, they make most of their money from Free Software --
RS: Right. And they're not contributing when they write their manuals. They're not contributions to our community. That's why I encourage people not to buy them.
MB: Really?!
RS: Really.
MB: They're some of the best... They _are_ the best --
RS: I don't care if they're the best. I don't care if a program is technically best. If it's not _free_, I won't use it.
MB: Right... Now, computer software's one thing. That's kind of a weirdo geek business, but when you start talking about books, and music --
RS: Right. Those as I said are not _exactly_ the same issue. They're partly similar and partly different.
For them, I think, because we don't have the need to be publishing modified versions, I think that therefore a system that allowed everyone to make occasional verbatim copies for their friends would be tolerable.
MB: Have you thought about doing, say, a GNU Content License? For people who want to develop so-called Free Content.
RS: It's very simple. If you want to do that, it's very simple. You just say "Verbatim copying of this document is permitted in any medium provided this notice is preserved."
MB: That's easy.
RS: Plus a copyright notice. And you'll notice that that's what we do for things that are not *technical documentation*. The things that state philosophy. Things that state our legal position. Things where we talk about our history, things like that.
For anything other than manuals or documentation for software, that's what we do. And very simple.
ES: What about, uh, documentation that's written by multiple people, and maintained by multiple people. Would that convert, for something like that?
RS: Well, for documentation, you know, you can use a simple copyleft like the one we use on GNU manuals and the one that I proposed for the quote "Linux Documentation Project" unquote.
|
NM: I've got a copy of the GCC manual here [reaches over and grabs a book off one of the bookshelves]. RS: I'm thinking about putting in a requirement about that -- adding a requirement about preserving the authorship information. NM: It says [NOTE: put that long license thing in here. Or not.] |
 The Inimitable Nick Moffit |
MB: [sotto voce, into tape recorder] Cut and paste this from somewhere. You don't have to type this all out. Thanks.
RS: What that is is an example of a simple copyleft for a manual. The reason that I use that kind of simple copyleft is that the issue about source code is not the same for a manual as it is for a program.
If you've got a printed copy of a manual, you see all the words. Whereas if you've got a binary of a program you don't see what the source code says. It's true that it's convenient to have the source code available, and we do make the source code available.
But if somebody did publish a modified version and didn't release the source code in online form, at least you'd see what all the words were in the modified version and you could type them in if you really wanted to. Which is much easier -- it's some work -- but it's much easier than figuring out the source code --
MB: Decompiling.
RS: Yeah, and figuring out what the symbol names are and how everything should -- Y'know, there's nothing hidden in a text to be read. So that's why I don't put in something requiring people to release modified versions as machine-readable source.
MB: Cool.
RS: This is why I don't use the GPL for manuals. I don't need something as complicated as the GPL for a manual. We do need it for software. It deals with issues that only apply to software.
Anyway, the reason why manuals should be treated differently from just anything else that you might write is that manuals belong in the software.
MB: They're a part of it.
RS: And when you change the program, if you want to do a thorough job, you ought to modify the manual, too. And therefore you better be free to publish the modified manual.
T O P S T O R I E S
California Glory Hole attracts huge crowds
A glory hole at Napa's Lake Berryessa is drawing huge crowds. According to Chris Lee, the general manager for the Solano County Water Agency, the glory hole hasn't been active since 2019, and only restarted operations on Feb 4. (More...)
Republican State Senator busted after soliciting a teenage girl
Republican State Senator Justin Eichorn of Minnesota was arrested for soliciting a teen girl on Monday just hours after he introduced a bill proposing "Trump derangement syndrome" (TDS) as a form of mental illness. (More...)
Parents claim measles is not that bad after having only one child die
The parents of a Texas girl who died from the measles are defending their decision not to vaccinate their daughter. "She says they would still say 'Don't do the shots,'" an unidentified translator for the parents said. "They think it’s not as bad as the media is making it out to be." (More...)
Delusional rich man tries to fire town staff
"I'm mayor now" said write-in mayoral candidate and founder of Pirate’s Booty Snacks Robert Ehrlich after losing the election for Mayor of Sea Cliff, NY. Then he tried to take over the Village Hall and fire everyone. (More...)
Musk claims Xitter security is staffed by idiots
Earlier this month Xitter experienced a massive outage. In an interview, Musk told Fox Business that he believes the attack came from "IP addresses originating in the Ukraine area." (More...)
The Future Ain't What It Used To Be
Ideas have taken horrifying shape and rooted into our modern reality. (More...)
C L A S S I C P I G D O G
One of our star reporters was sent to Comdex by his employer. El Destino reports live from the biggest, geekiest trade show in the world. (More...)
There are two kinds of Assmen in this world. Wild, hairy assmen, who put stickers that say things like "Why Be Normal?" all over their trucks and drink Corona beer and wear fezzes at parties for attention; these are the Assman Desperados. Our job is to ferret them out and expose them. (More...)
Poor Metallica. All they want is to continue to put out the same weak "Heavy Metal" they've been churning out since the "And Justice For All" days? and make gooey wads of cash in the process. The problem is, people aren't buying their bound for the heavy metal scrap heap, over-produced, uninspired, tired crap. And let's face it, their various commercial endorsements won't pay for the lifestyle they've become comfortably accustomed to. Resorting to lawsuits makes perfect sense, when you need spending money. But just one lawsuit isn't going to pay their bills. So, to aid Metallica, I've composed an open letter to the boys in the band, with suggestions as to whom else they might sic their lapdog lawyers on... (More...)
About 14 years ago when I was on a road trip and stopped in Seattle, I was invited to a party. At this party there were these little tiny glasses sitting in a flat-bottomed bowl of ice. Thin cylinders about an inch in diameter and 4 inches tall, with thick glass at the bottom. Into these were poured frozen AKVAVIT... also known as the water of life. (More...)
Three Days and 25 Spocktails: A Cautionary Tale
Johnnie Royale picked me up from the dental surgery. I felt warm, safe, cradled in the anathesia's loving embrace. The pharmacy downstairs gave me a bottle of Vicodin and a few instructions: take it with food, don't mix with alcohol, don't operate heavy machinery. I put it in my pocket and we left. "Do you want to go home, or do you want to go to a bar?" asked Johnnie. (More...)
Johnnie Royale's Guide to Wakes
Wakes can present problems for Bad People of the Future. (If you don't know what a BPotF is, you need to read more of the PDJ.) Sure, your friend is gone and you miss him and that really sucks; it does, I know. But all Bad People of the Future are gonna die, and they have all accepted that fact. They do deserve, however, to have one final kickass party to celebrate all the bad things they've done in the past, present and future. And you, as a friend, have to make sure that their desire for a final send off is well executed (sorry for the pun). That's just the way of BPotFdom. (More...)
